Published in the July/August 2007 issue
Interview: Colin Clark
BACK TO PAGE ONE
Chocolate teapot
Being the only person with access to the system is a big responsibility.
“It’s actually pretty easy to run,” says Clark.
“There are so many companies that offer the exact same service
as our Enterprise Vault, but they do the work for you. It’s
as useful as a chocolate teapot. These companies do what I do myself
with very little time or energy, and they charge you for that privilege”.
Legally, business information relating to the likes of accounts
should be retained for six years, due to tax and property rules.
“We’ve now got about 30 million emails stored since
the end of 2000. The problem is, the moment you start deleting records,
how do you prove that what you have left is everything?”
How long can the data be retained before the value of keeping
it is outweighed by the cost to retain it? “As the information
becomes older, we would actually move it on to even cheaper storage.
As it was, the system paid for itself within three months of installation,”
says Clark.
Blocking spam, cutting costs
With email storage taken care of, what else keeps Colin Clark up
at night? “I can tell you what doesn’t,” he replies
smugly, “spam”. Somerfield entrusts its anti-spam protection
to SurfControl. “It’s a lovely piece of software where
you can define all of your own rules, and rather importantly, it’s
invisible to the user,” says Clark.
“We were getting 100 000 external emails coming in every
week – many containing explicit content. SurfControl now blocks
80 000 emails on a weekly basis,” he says. “If it takes
two minutes for somebody to look at a spam email to realise it’s
rubbish, and we’re getting 80 000 less emails a week, SurfControl
are saving us 160 000 minutes a week. It’s not the staff on
the shop floor getting £6 an hour receiving email either,
it’s the people higher up. Their hourly rate is a lot higher
and therefore saving 160 000 minutes of their wage is pretty significant.”
“We have a responsibility towards our staff and they shouldn’t
be subject to this kind of stuff in the work place,” he says.
“We kept getting emails saying ‘would you like to enlarge
your penis?’. One of our female colleagues responded by saying
‘there’s enough big dicks around here anyway, so get
rid of it’. It just works.”
Confidently secure
A SafeNet survey published in
June revealed that only one quarter of IT security professionals
have full confidence in their network security. Is Clark amongst
this minority? “Yes. Absolutely. We handle over two million
credit card transactions a week, we have to be confident in our
security.”
So what’s the secret? “We have an outsourced IT department
who are very professional. On top of that we have the PCI standard*
where external auditors audit us annually, and report to us on our
security capability. On top of that, I use external companies to
do penetration testing on various elements of the system that I
don’t have 100% confidence in, or if there is a new technology
coming out that is giving me fear.”
“I’ve got a company coming in purely to do wireless
network testing, for example. We have both secured and unsecured
(which go to a safe area outside the firewall) wireless networks
in this building and we use mobile networking. We also have external
access via broadband, and we have BlackBerries.”
“These things go missing though. I’ve had my own laptop
stolen, and was deeply embarrassed,” admits Clark sheepishly.
“We do have a policy in place where usernames and passwords
are forced to change monthly, and we don’t use single sign-on,
it’s too dangerous.”
Clark is unfazed by other retailers’ stories of accidental
credit card retention. “What has actually happened in the
TK Maxx scandal? Have you heard of thousands of people losing money
out of it? No, it was blown way out of proportion. So all those
credit card numbers were leaked, but what damage can actually be
done without mag strips, security codes?”
“Somerfield used to retain customers’ credit details,
but under PCI, we no longer do,” he adds. “Retaining
customers’ credit details means you can monitor their spending
habits, which is what Tesco and Sainsbury’s use their loyalty
card schemes to do.” Although this may seem Orwellian to the
shopper, for supermarkets it sounds like an ingenuous way of gathering
market research. So why have Somerfield not bought into this idea?
“We used to have a loyalty scheme but it raised huge data
protection issues, like money laundering,” says Clark. “All
loyalty cards do is encourage an alcoholic to buy more booze, or
somebody who buys lots of ready meals to buy even more and get obese.”
“And it was costing us millions,” he adds, perhaps
more meaningfully.
Rip-off and PIN
Amongst two million credit card transactions every week, incidents
of fraud must be as common as ‘buy one – get one free’
offers? “Yes, but much less so since Chip and PIN, which is
the biggest scandal you’ve ever heard in your life,”
Clark replies. “It’s designed to protect the customer,
but all it does is push the banks’ losses away from them and
on to the retailer. The banks’ money is the only thing that’s
being saved. It does nothing for the customer or the retailer. If
we don’t verify the PIN number, we’re liable for any
losses – it’s the biggest scam there ever was.”
“We have a very secure environment where we keep all of
our till transactions. We use data mining to investigate fraud,
which allows us to identify criminal activity. It’s about
making sure we always move forward with new technology and new crime
patterns.”
Somerfield has grown partly through mergers and acquisitions,
which in terms of security can be problematic. “The biggest
problem with mergers is a lack of continuity. For example, you’ll
remove a person who does the job, but not the risk that they protect
against. This is when gaps appear – and the key is in identifying
risks of gaps.”
“It’s my job to make risk assessments on a daily basis
– I have to question whether the potential consequence of
the risk is enough to put a defence in place, and analyse whether
it’s financially worth it. It’s important to realise
that it’s not just about security – it’s about
de-risk.”
“After all, our job is not to be the best security company
in the world, we just need to protect our staff and our customers
without disabling the assets.”
More from July/August 2007
Tony Bradley, author of recently-published Syngress title PCI Compliance:
Understand and Implement Effective PCI Data Security Standard Compliance,
writes for Infosecurity on the
new standard
PCI: Here to stay - an
introduction to the controversial payment card security standard
Features index
|